Discover Original Herkimer Cheese –
A True Taste of New York Craftsmanship
Experience the rich, creamy flavor of Original Herkimer Cheese, a beloved family-crafted cheese with roots in Herkimer County, New York, spanning over 70 years. Today, it’s craftfully made by Old Chatham Creamery, just a few hours from its original home, continuing a tradition of artisan excellence. Original Herkimer Cheese offers a range of artisan cheese products that showcase its classic New York–style cheddar in different formats and flavor profiles, often made as specialty cheese balls/logs.
Why You’ll Love It
Rich, Handcrafted Flavor
Every bite of Original Herkimer Cheese delivers smooth, buttery, full-bodied cheddar that reflects decades of artisan cheesemaking.
Creamy & Spreadable
Its silky, buttery texture spreads easily on crackers, breads, and sandwiches, turning simple snacks into indulgent moments.
Versatile & Delicious
Original Herkimer Cheese melts, spreads, and pairs beautifully, making it a staple for snacks, entertaining, or special moments.
Crafted with Care
Every batch of Original Herkimer Cheese is made using premium New York ingredients and time-honored techniques.
Perfect for Every Occasion
Whether you’re hosting friends, making a family snack, or looking for a gift that truly stands out, Original Herkimer Cheese brings artisan quality and indulgent taste to every table.
Cheese Balls & Logs
Traditional cheese balls and logs made from cheddar are a signature style of Original Herkimer Cheese — perfect for cheese platters or gatherings. Flavors include:
Cheddar
The classic choice, made from rich, creamy cheddar. Smooth, buttery, and mildly tangy, this cheese ball is a crowd-pleaser that pairs effortlessly with crackers, nuts, and fresh fruit. Its familiar, full-bodied flavor makes it perfect for any cheese board or casual gathering.
Port Wine
A sophisticated blend of creamy cheddar and sweet, fruity port wine. The wine adds a gentle richness and a hint of sweetness that balances the cheddar’s savory depth. Perfect for entertaining or gifting, this cheese ball adds elegance to any platter.
Garlic & Herb A zesty, aromatic option that combines creamy cheddar with roasted garlic and a mix of fresh herbs. The bold, savory flavors make this cheese ball ideal for parties and casual snacking alike. Its herbal notes elevate even simple crackers or bread.
Merlot
This cheese ball marries sharp cheddar with the rich, fruity notes of Merlot wine. Smooth, slightly tangy, and subtly sweet, it delivers a sophisticated flavor profile that appeals to wine and cheese lovers alike.
Smoked Gouda Cheese
A bold twist on a classic favorite, this cheese ball blends creamy cheddar with rich smoked Gouda for a perfectly balanced flavor. The result is a smooth, savory bite layered with smoky depth and a buttery, slightly sweet finish. Ideal for those who appreciate a more robust and distinctive cheese experience.
Half Moons
Half Moons are semi-firm, wedge-shaped cheeses with a distinctive “half-moon” profile — rounded on one side and flat on the other for easy slicing and serving. Available in classic Cheddar or Port Wine, they’re perfect for cheese boards, sandwiches, or snacking.
Variety Packs
Each trio assortment brings together three of the Original Herkimer Cheese cold‑pack cheeses in one convenient pack, perfect for sharing or trying multiple favorites at once.
Original Herkimer Cheese Variety Pack:
-
Extra Sharp Cheddar – rich, tangy, and bold with the classic cheddar flavor the brand is known for.
-
Port Wine – creamy cheddar blended with port wine for a slightly fruity, subtly sweet note.
-
Garlic & Herbs – savory roasted garlic and aromatic herbs mixed into creamy cheddar for extra flavor.
Together, this pack is a classic sampler of Original Herkimer Cheese's signature varieties – a great way to try a few of our most popular flavors in one convenient package.
Original Herkimer Tailgate Trio:
-
Green Onion: Bright, savory scallion notes add a fresh twist to creamy cheese.
-
Cheesy Bacon: A rich, smoky bacon flavor blended with cheddar for classic comfort.
-
Spicy Tomato: Zesty tomato spice brings a little heat and boldness to the mix.
Together, the trio makes for an easy, shareable spread that stands out on snack tables, game day spreads, or casual party platters.
Original Herkimer Elegant Trio:
-
Merlot: A creamy cheddar base enhanced with fruity Merlot wine notes for a smooth, subtly sweet taste.
-
Smoked Gouda: Combines rich cheddar with smoky Gouda for a bold, savory profile.
-
Port Wine: Cheddar blended with port wine, offering a slightly fruity finish that pairs beautifully with crackers and fruit.
Together, this pack gives a balanced mix of classic, smoky, and wine accented flavors — ideal for cheese boards, entertaining, or gifting.
